Scientific Findings on Breathwork

Written By Evan Drake

Introduction

Breathwork refers to a broad range of practices involving deliberate control of breathing to improve mental, emotional, or physical health ( Effect of breathwork on stress and mental health: A meta-analysis of randomised-controlled trials - PMC ). These practices have roots in ancient traditions (e.g. yogic pranayama, Tibetan breathing) as well as modern therapeutic and even psychedelic contexts ( Effect of breathwork on stress and mental health: A meta-analysis of randomised-controlled trials - PMC ). In recent years, breathwork has gained popularity as a simple, drug-free method for stress relief and self-improvement, though scientific research is only beginning to catch up with the public interest ( Effect of breathwork on stress and mental health: A meta-analysis of randomised-controlled trials - PMC ). Somatic breathwork is a particular approach that emphasizes the connection between breath, bodily sensations, and emotions. It’s considered a “bottom-up” therapeutic technique – starting with physical sensation to influence mental state – in contrast to “top-down” talk therapies focused on thoughts (Somatic Breathwork | Charlie Health). Somatic breathwork is often used in trauma therapy and stress reduction, aligning with the broader field of somatic therapy that integrates mind and body in healing (Somatic Breathwork | Charlie Health). While many anecdotal reports attest to the benefits of somatic breathwork, it’s important to note that specific scientific evidence for somatic techniques remains limited so far (Somatics: Definition, Exercises, Evidence, and More). This report summarizes what current science – including clinical trials, neuroscience studies, and systematic reviews – tells us about the physiological and psychological effects of breathwork. It also outlines different breathwork techniques (with a focus on somatic methods and related practices), highlights recent research findings (mostly from the last decade), profiles leading researchers in the field, and discusses open questions, gaps, and some surprising discoveries about breathwork.

Physiological Effects of Breathwork

Breathwork can induce significant physiological changes in the body, especially via its impact on the autonomic nervous system, brain activity, and even the endocrine and immune systems. A 2018 systematic review of slow-breathing practices (<10 breaths per minute) found clear effects on both the autonomic and central nervous systems ( How Breath-Control Can Change Your Life: A Systematic Review on Psycho-Physiological Correlates of Slow Breathing - PMC ). Slow, diaphragmatic breathing tends to shift the body toward parasympathetic (“rest and digest”) dominance: studies report increased heart rate variability (HRV) and enhanced respiratory sinus arrhythmia, indicating greater vagal tone and relaxation ( How Breath-Control Can Change Your Life: A Systematic Review on Psycho-Physiological Correlates of Slow Breathing - PMC ). Concurrently, breathing exercises can modulate brain activity. EEG measurements during slow breathing show increased alpha waves (associated with calm wakefulness) and decreased theta waves ( How Breath-Control Can Change Your Life: A Systematic Review on Psycho-Physiological Correlates of Slow Breathing - PMC ), while fMRI scans have revealed enhanced activity in brain regions involved in emotion regulation and interoception (e.g. prefrontal cortex, pons, and hypothalamus) during controlled breathing ( How Breath-Control Can Change Your Life: A Systematic Review on Psycho-Physiological Correlates of Slow Breathing - PMC ). These physiological shifts correspond with a calmer but alert state: participants report feeling more comfort and relaxation and less anxiety or arousal after breathwork sessions ( How Breath-Control Can Change Your Life: A Systematic Review on Psycho-Physiological Correlates of Slow Breathing - PMC ) ( How Breath-Control Can Change Your Life: A Systematic Review on Psycho-Physiological Correlates of Slow Breathing - PMC ).

One reason breathwork influences so many body systems is that breathing is directly tied into the brainstem networks controlling arousal. Notably, neuroscientists have identified a specific cluster of neurons in the brainstem that links respiration to the brain’s arousal center. In a landmark 2017 study, researchers at Stanford showed that a tiny set of pacemaker neurons for breathing can send signals to the locus coeruleus (which regulates alertness); in mice, removing these neurons (essentially disconnecting slow breathing from the arousal center) made the animals unusually calm (Study shows how slow breathing induces tranquility) (Study shows how slow breathing induces tranquility). This finding gives a cellular basis for why slowing the breath induces tranquility (Study shows how slow breathing induces tranquility) – it literally turns down the alarm signals sent from the respiratory center to the brain’s arousal circuits. It also supports earlier theories like polyvagal theory, proposed by Stephen Porges, which posits that elongating the exhale and engaging the diaphragm stimulates the vagus nerve and shifts the body into a relaxed state ( Effect of breathwork on stress and mental health: A meta-analysis of randomised-controlled trials - PMC ).

Beyond the nervous system, breathwork can alter levels of hormones and inflammatory markers. Certain intense breathing techniques activate the sympathetic “fight-or-flight” response transiently in a controlled way, leading to measurable biochemical changes. For example, the Wim Hof Method – which involves cycles of hyperventilation and breath retention combined with cold exposure – was shown to produce a surge of epinephrine (adrenaline) and a subsequent anti-inflammatory effect. In one randomized experiment, practitioners trained in this method had remarkably higher epinephrine levels and an increase in the anti-inflammatory cytokine IL-10, alongside reduced pro-inflammatory cytokines, after an endotoxin challenge ( Does the Wim Hof Method have a beneficial impact on physiological and psychological outcomes in healthy and non-healthy participants? A systematic review - PMC ) ( Does the Wim Hof Method have a beneficial impact on physiological and psychological outcomes in healthy and non-healthy participants? A systematic review - PMC ). In practical terms, this means that voluntary breathwork training enabled participants to dampen the normal inflammatory response – a surprising demonstration of mind-body control over the immune system. Breathing exercises also influence heart rate and blood pressure via mechanical and reflex mechanisms. Slow, deep breathing exercises (around 6 breaths per minute, sometimes called coherent or resonant breathing) engage baroreflexes that stabilize blood pressure; studies have found that such breathing can lower heart rate and blood pressure in hypertensive patients and improve exercise tolerance in cardiac rehab ( Brief structured respiration practices enhance mood and reduce physiological arousal - PMC ). Similarly, asthma patients practicing breath regulation techniques (like the Buteyko method or pranayama breathing) often show improved lung function, less airway reactivity, and reduced need for bronchodilator medication ( Brief structured respiration practices enhance mood and reduce physiological arousal - PMC ). Researchers have also begun exploring how nasal breathing versus mouth breathing affects the brain: evidence shows that nasal breathing produces rhythmic activity in the olfactory cortex, amygdala, and hippocampus (areas tied to emotion and memory), which is absent during mouth breathing ( Brief structured respiration practices enhance mood and reduce physiological arousal - PMC ). This hints that the route of air (nose vs. mouth) can modulate neural oscillations and possibly cognitive function – an intriguing new frontier in breathwork physiology.

In summary, controlled breathing techniques have multifaceted physiological effects. They can recalibrate autonomic balance (shifting the body into a calmer state), alter brain wave patterns and connectivity, and even trigger endocrine and immune changes. These bodily shifts form the foundation for many of the psychological benefits reported with breathwork, as discussed next.

Psychological and Emotional Effects

A major draw of breathwork is its ability to positively influence mental health and emotional well-being. A growing body of clinical research supports breathwork’s efficacy in reducing stress, anxiety, and mood disturbances. A recent 2023 meta-analysis pooled data from 12 randomized controlled trials (785 total participants) and found that breathwork interventions were associated with significantly lower perceived stress levels compared to control conditions (effect size g ≈ –0.35, p < 0.001) ( Effect of breathwork on stress and mental health: A meta-analysis of randomised-controlled trials - PMC ). Likewise, in that analysis breathwork produced small-to-moderate improvements in anxiety and depressive symptoms (g ≈ –0.32 for anxiety, –0.40 for depression, both p < 0.0001) relative to controls ( Effect of breathwork on stress and mental health: A meta-analysis of randomised-controlled trials - PMC ). These findings suggest that, on average, practicing breath regulation can meaningfully alleviate negative emotions and improve mood. Importantly, these benefits have been observed across a range of breathing styles – from slow, deep breathing to more stimulating techniques – indicating a broad therapeutic potential for different populations.

Clinical trials targeting specific disorders also demonstrate breathwork’s promise. In patients with diagnosed anxiety disorders (such as generalized anxiety or panic disorder), breathing-based techniques have led to significant reductions in anxiety symptoms according to a 2023 scoping review ( Breathwork Interventions for Adults with Clinically Diagnosed Anxiety Disorders: A Scoping Review - PMC ). Some protocols use hyperventilation exercises deliberately as exposure therapy for panic (to blunt fear of bodily sensations), while others use slow breathing to prevent over-breathing – interestingly, both approaches have shown benefit, though results can vary by individual ( Breathwork Interventions for Adults with Clinically Diagnosed Anxiety Disorders: A Scoping Review - PMC ). For PTSD and trauma, breathing practices are being incorporated as well: for example, a controlled trial on war veterans found that a breathing-based meditation (Sudarshan Kriya Yoga, involving cyclic breath patterns) significantly reduced PTSD symptoms and anxiety levels, with improvements persisting months later (veterans, breath, project welcome home troops, PWHT) (Yogic breathing shows promise in reducing symptoms of PTSD). In depression, emerging research suggests breathwork can augment mood and energy; some therapists report that engaging the body through breath helps “unstick” emotional processing when talk therapy alone falters. While more studies on depression are underway, initial results are encouraging enough that breathing techniques are being recommended as low-risk adjunct interventions in psychiatry (The Healing Power of the Breath: Simple Techniques to Reduce ...).

Breathwork also enhances positive feelings and mental well-being. Participants often describe greater calmness, clarity, and even vigor after completing breathing exercises ( How Breath-Control Can Change Your Life: A Systematic Review on Psycho-Physiological Correlates of Slow Breathing - PMC ) ( How Breath-Control Can Change Your Life: A Systematic Review on Psycho-Physiological Correlates of Slow Breathing - PMC ). A striking example comes from a 2022 randomized trial at Stanford: one month of daily 5-minute breathwork exercises led to greater improvements in mood and anxiety reduction than 5 minutes of daily mindfulness meditation practice ( Brief structured respiration practices enhance mood and reduce physiological arousal - PMC ) ( Brief structured respiration practices enhance mood and reduce physiological arousal - PMC ). In that study, a technique emphasizing slow, elongated exhalations (“cyclic sighing”) was the most effective at boosting mood and reducing physiological arousal, even more so than the meditation control or other breathing patterns ( Brief structured respiration practices enhance mood and reduce physiological arousal - PMC ) ( Brief structured respiration practices enhance mood and reduce physiological arousal - PMC ). This suggests that short, consistent breathing practices can rapidly improve emotional state, perhaps by providing a quick shift in physiology that people subjectively experience as relief. Indeed, both breathwork and meditation are beneficial for stress, but breathwork may yield quicker gains in certain measures of mood and calmness ( Brief structured respiration practices enhance mood and reduce physiological arousal - PMC ) ( Brief structured respiration practices enhance mood and reduce physiological arousal - PMC ).

Another psychological dimension of breathwork is its role in trauma release and self-exploration. Somatic breathwork practitioners report that conscious breathing in a safe setting can help surface and process repressed emotions or traumatic memories stored in the body. While scientific validation of these claims is nascent, there are case reports and qualitative studies (for example, in holotropic breathwork sessions) where individuals achieve catharsis or new insights after intense breathing-induced altered states. In a controlled study of Holotropic Breathwork (a technique involving prolonged hyperventilation), participants showed positive changes in temperament and self-awareness, along with reductions in hostility and interpersonal problems ( Measure of Significance of Holotropic Breathwork in the Development of Self-Awareness - PMC ) ( Measure of Significance of Holotropic Breathwork in the Development of Self-Awareness - PMC ). These psychological shifts, measured by personality and clinical scales, hint that even a short series of breathwork sessions can facilitate personal growth or emotional adjustment. However, some participants also experienced temporary increases in unusual perceptions (e.g. a rise in a paranoia scale, albeit within normal range), highlighting that the profound experiences during breathwork can sometimes be challenging ( Measure of Significance of Holotropic Breathwork in the Development of Self-Awareness - PMC ) ( Measure of Significance of Holotropic Breathwork in the Development of Self-Awareness - PMC ). This underscores the importance of skilled facilitation and aftercare when using breathwork for deep emotional work.

In summary, breathwork has demonstrated therapeutic effects on mental health, from reducing everyday stress and anxiety to serving as a tool in treating trauma-related conditions. Users frequently report feeling calmer, more grounded, and emotionally balanced after breathing sessions. The science corroborates many of these benefits, showing reductions in stress hormones, shifts toward parasympathetic dominance, and improved self-reported mood. That said, individual experiences can vary widely – some techniques energize and stimulate, while others soothe and center – so the psychological impact of breathwork can be highly technique-dependent, as explored below.

Breathwork Techniques and Approaches

There is a rich diversity of breathwork techniques, each with its own style and intended effects. Here we discuss several notable approaches, including somatic breathwork and related practices, and what is known about them:

  • Somatic Breathwork: Somatic breathwork is embedded in the larger field of somatic therapy, which uses the body’s sensations and movements as entry points for healing trauma, stress, and emotional blocks. In somatic breathwork sessions, individuals practice conscious breathing while maintaining mindful awareness of bodily feelings, often guided by a facilitator. The goal is to release tension or emotion that may be “held” in the body and to integrate mind-body awareness. Somatic breathwork can include techniques like deep diaphragmatic breathing, vocal exhalations (sighs, sounds), or rhythmic breathing patterns, combined with introspection. Therapists describe this as working from the “bottom-up” – using physical change (breath and posture) to influence mental state (Somatic Breathwork | Charlie Health). It has been applied to conditions like PTSD, anxiety, and chronic stress with many anecdotal successes (Somatic Breathwork | Charlie Health), but as noted, dedicated scientific studies on somatic-focused breathwork are still limited (Somatics: Definition, Exercises, Evidence, and More). Nevertheless, it draws on established principles (such as breathing to activate the parasympathetic nervous system (Somatic Breathwork | Charlie Health)) and overlaps with other well-studied techniques like diaphragmatic breathing and mindfulness of breath.

  • Diaphragmatic and Coherent Breathing: One of the simplest forms of breathwork taught in both clinical and wellness settings is slow diaphragmatic breathing. This involves breathing deeply into the belly (engaging the diaphragm) at a slow rate, often around 5–6 breaths per minute, with smooth inhales and exhales. Sometimes a specific count is used, such as inhaling for 4 seconds, exhaling for 6 seconds, etc., to prolong the exhale. This style of breathing maximizes HRV and has been termed coherent breathing or resonance breathing because it can synchronize heart, lung, and blood pressure rhythms. Numerous studies show that diaphragmatic breathing can reduce anxiety, lower blood pressure, and improve cognitive focus by improving oxygenation and reducing sympathetic overactivity ( How Breath-Control Can Change Your Life: A Systematic Review on Psycho-Physiological Correlates of Slow Breathing - PMC ) ( Brief structured respiration practices enhance mood and reduce physiological arousal - PMC ). Variations of this include box breathing (a technique popular among Navy SEALs and athletes), which is a cyclical 4-4-4-4 second inhale-hold-exhale-hold pattern intended to calm and focus the mind. Box breathing and similar rhythmic breathing exercises help regulate the autonomic nervous system and are easy to practice in almost any setting, making them widely used for immediate stress management.

  • Yogic Breathing (Pranayama): Pranayama, the breath regulation branch of yoga, encompasses a wide array of techniques developed over millennia. These include Ujjayi breathing (victorious breath, characterized by a slight constriction in the throat to create a sound), Nadi Shodhana (alternate-nostril breathing), Bhastrika (bellows breath, a rapid inhale/exhale practice), Bhramari (bee breath with humming on exhale), among others. Yogic breathing techniques can be stimulating or calming: for example, alternate-nostril breathing is traditionally said to balance the nervous system, and research shows it can reduce blood pressure and anxiety, possibly by promoting equal activation of both brain hemispheres. Slow pranayama practices overlap with the slow breathing we discussed earlier – for instance, a common yoga recommendation is to lengthen the exhale and pause briefly after exhalation, which increases vagal tone. There is a substantial body of research from India and beyond on pranayama. Studies have documented improvements in respiratory function, metabolic parameters, and stress markers from regular pranayama practice ( How Breath-Control Can Change Your Life: A Systematic Review on Psycho-Physiological Correlates of Slow Breathing - PMC ) ( How Breath-Control Can Change Your Life: A Systematic Review on Psycho-Physiological Correlates of Slow Breathing - PMC ). One specific sequence, Sudarshan Kriya Yoga (SKY), alternates slow, medium, and rapid breaths in a cyclical pattern; SKY has been studied in both healthy individuals and those with depression or PTSD, showing reductions in depression scores and PTSD symptoms compared to waitlist controls (veterans, breath, project welcome home troops, PWHT) (Yogic breathing shows promise in reducing symptoms of PTSD). Overall, yogic breathwork is one of the most empirically supported categories, underpinning many mindfulness and meditation programs with its emphasis on conscious breathing.

  • Holotropic and Conscious Connected Breathwork: Holotropic Breathwork is a highly experiential form of breathwork developed in the 1970s by psychiatrist Stanislav Grof and Christina Grof as a means to achieve altered states of consciousness similar to those in psychedelic therapy ( Measure of Significance of Holotropic Breathwork in the Development of Self-Awareness - PMC ). In holotropic sessions, participants lie down and engage in an extended period (often 2–3 hours) of continuous, deep, and fast breathing, usually accompanied by evocative music and occasionally bodywork by facilitators. This hyperventilative breathing lowers CO₂ levels and can induce tingling, emotional release, and visionary experiences. It is termed “holotropic” (meaning “moving toward wholeness”) because it aims to allow access to unconscious material for healing or personal growth. Research on holotropic breathwork is relatively sparse due to its non-traditional nature, but some studies and many observational reports suggest it can help with self-awareness and catharsis. For instance, a study in Denmark with four holotropic sessions found participants had significant positive changes in personality measures, like decreased hostility and increased self-transcendence, after the sessions ( Measure of Significance of Holotropic Breathwork in the Development of Self-Awareness - PMC ) ( Measure of Significance of Holotropic Breathwork in the Development of Self-Awareness - PMC ). “Conscious connected breathing” is a similar umbrella term for techniques that involve breathing with no pauses between inhale and exhale, often at a faster pace, to enter altered states (Rebirthing Breathwork is another variant from the 1960s and 70s). These techniques are reported to facilitate deep emotional releases and even transpersonal or spiritual insights. While scientific validation is in early stages, a very recent line of research is examining neurodynamic effects of such practices: a 2024 study using EEG found that breathwork sessions where participants reported “psychedelic-like” experiences were associated with increased neural signal complexity, analogous to the brain dynamics seen in pharmacological psychedelic states (Breathwork-induced psychedelic experiences modulate neural dynamics - PubMed) (Breathwork-induced psychedelic experiences modulate neural dynamics - PubMed). This is a fascinating convergence of ancient practice and modern neuroscience, suggesting that powerful breathing techniques can modulate brain networks in ways that resemble mind-altering substances.

  • Energizing Breathwork (Tummo, Wim Hof Method): Some breathwork methods deliberately push the body toward extreme states to build resilience and unlock unique benefits. Tummo meditation, practiced by Tibetan yogis, combines visualization with a forceful breathing technique to generate inner heat. Practitioners of tummo have been documented in scientific studies to raise their core body temperature and keep themselves warm in freezing conditions purely through breath and mind control (Mind over matter? Core body temperature controlled by the brain) (Meditation changes temperatures - Harvard Gazette). The Wim Hof Method (WHM) is a modern adaptation drawing from Tummo and pranayama, popularized by “Iceman” Wim Hof. It involves repeated rounds of fast deep breaths (hyperventilation) followed by breath retention on exhale, typically 30 breaths then a 1-2 minute hold, often done in the morning or before cold exposure. WHM breathing induces a short-term stress response (elevated adrenaline, as noted earlier) that paradoxically leads to a rebound activation of anti-stress pathways. Volunteers practicing the WHM have shown an ability to withstand immune and pain challenges better – in the notable endotoxin study, trained individuals reported fewer sickness symptoms and had significantly blunted inflammatory responses compared to untrained controls ( Does the Wim Hof Method have a beneficial impact on physiological and psychological outcomes in healthy and non-healthy participants? A systematic review - PMC ). From a psychological view, these energizing techniques are often reported to increase feelings of alertness, resilience, and euphoria after the session, likely due to endorphin release and the rush of adrenaline followed by a relaxation wave. Caution is advised with such methods, as they can cause lightheadedness or tingling (due to lowered CO₂) and are typically done lying down or seated to avoid falls. Still, controlled hyperventilation practices represent an exciting area where voluntary stress induction via breathing can lead to enhanced stress tolerance and physiological benefits – essentially using breath as a form of hormetic therapy.

Other Notable Techniques: There are many other breathing practices, including alternate-nostril breathing (which may improve cardiovascular rhythms and reduce stress), Kapalabhati or breath of fire (rapid diaphragmatic breathing to stimulate and cleanse, sometimes used in yoga kriyas), Lion’s breath (forceful exhale with tongue out, to release tension), and various modern “breathwork journeys” that combine breathing with music, hypnosis, or somatic movement. Additionally, heart-rate variability (HRV) biofeedback often centers on guiding individuals to breathe at their personal resonant frequency (around 6 breaths/minute) to maximize vagal tone – a practice that has shown benefit for anxiety, PTSD, and even conditions like IBS by strengthening autonomic regulation (Breath Practices for Survivor and Caregiver Stress, Depression, and ...). This illustrates how breathwork spans from very gentle, mindful breathing to highly intense, altered-state-inducing practices. Each technique engages the body-mind connection in a slightly different way, but all share the core principle of using conscious breath manipulation to influence one’s physiology and consciousness.

Recent Scientific Studies and Findings (2015–2025)

Scientific interest in breathwork has surged in the past decade, yielding some high-quality studies and reviews. Here we highlight a few key recent findings and advances from roughly 2015 onward:

Overall, the last decade of research has greatly expanded our understanding of breathwork. Studies from cellular neuroscience to clinical trials are converging to validate that how we breathe can deeply affect how we feel and even how our bodies function at a biochemical level. Yet, as the next section addresses, many questions remain unanswered, and breathwork research is still in its early days for some of the more complex claims.

Leading Researchers and Key Contributors

Breathwork research spans multiple disciplines, from psychiatry to physiology to neuroscience. Some of the leading figures and contributors in this field include:

  • Dr. Stanislav Grof – A psychiatrist and pioneer of transpersonal psychology, Grof co-developed Holotropic Breathwork in the 1970s as a legal, drug-free method to explore altered states of consciousness ( Measure of Significance of Holotropic Breathwork in the Development of Self-Awareness - PMC ). Through workshops and observations, he and his late wife Christina Grof documented thousands of breathwork sessions, finding that participants often reported re-experiencing birth memories, processing trauma, or having spiritual insights. While Grof’s work was initially outside mainstream science, it laid the groundwork for viewing breathwork as a serious therapeutic tool. Today, researchers exploring breath-induced non-ordinary states owe a debt to Grof’s early theories and detailed reports.

  • Dr. Richard Brown & Dr. Patricia Gerbarg – A husband-and-wife team (both psychiatrists) who have been at the forefront of integrating breathwork into clinical psychiatry. They developed the Breath-Body-Mind program, which uses coherent breathing, breath counting, and gentle movement to help patients with anxiety, depression, PTSD, and survivors of mass disasters (Breathing practices for treatment of psychiatric and stress-related ...) (The Healing Power of the Breath: Simple Techniques to Reduce ...). Since the mid-2000s, Brown and Gerbarg have authored numerous papers and a widely read book The Healing Power of the Breath. They have documented cases and pilot studies showing breathing techniques can reduce PTSD symptoms in disaster survivors and improve mood and cognitive function in patients with depression. They were among the first to call for breathwork to be “prescribed” as an adjunct treatment in psychiatry, and they continue to train healthcare professionals in breathing techniques. Their work has lent credibility to breathwork in medical circles, and they often bridge Eastern practices (like Sudarshan Kriya Yoga) with Western science by conducting and compiling research on these methods.

  • Dr. Stephen Porges – While not a breathwork researcher per se, Porges is the neuroscientist behind the Polyvagal Theory, which has heavily influenced breathwork practice and research. Polyvagal theory emphasizes the role of the vagus nerve in emotional regulation and trauma, and it provides a theoretical framework for why slow, controlled breathing – especially with elongated exhalations – can calm the nervous system by activating the vagal brake ( Effect of breathwork on stress and mental health: A meta-analysis of randomised-controlled trials - PMC ). Porges’ work has been cited in many breathwork studies to explain observed increases in HRV and relaxation. He is considered a thought leader on how breathing and heart rate variability are linked to psychological safety and social connection, and he often collaborates with clinicians to apply these principles (e.g., in treating PTSD or autism-related anxiety). His influence is seen whenever researchers measure HRV or vagal tone as an outcome of breathwork interventions.

  • Dr. Jack Feldman & Dr. Mark Krasnow – Two eminent neurobiologists who uncovered the workings of the respiratory pacemaker in the brain. Jack Feldman (UCLA) first identified the pre-Bötzinger complex in the brainstem as the center generating rhythmic breathing. Mark Krasnow (Stanford) and Kevin Yackle (now at UCSF) later found the subset of neurons within that complex that project to the arousal systems (Study shows how slow breathing induces tranquility). Their collaborative research, published in Science (2017), was pivotal in explaining how breath control can influence emotional state at the neural level. These scientists typically work with animal models, but their discoveries are frequently cited by human studies as the biological basis for breathwork’s effects. Feldman has even speculated on how ancient yogis essentially “hacked” the breathing system that evolution provided. Together, Feldman, Krasnow, and Yackle have advanced our fundamental knowledge of the breathing-brain connection.

  • Dr. Luciano Bernardi – An Italian physiologist known for his groundbreaking studies on slow breathing and the cardiovascular system. In the early 2000s, Bernardi published experiments showing that reciting the Ave Maria prayer or Om mani padme hum mantra – both of which naturally pace breathing at around 6 breaths per minute – induced strong respiratory sinus arrhythmia and baroreflex engagement, leading to increased heart-brain coherence. He demonstrated that this slow breathing could improve exercise tolerance at high altitude and help chronic heart failure patients. Over the last decade, his work inspired many clinical trials on resonant breathing for health. Bernardi’s rigorous approach helped convince Western medicine that something as simple as breathing rate could have quantifiable effects on circulation and autonomic balance, and he remains a leading voice on breathing for cardiorespiratory health.

  • Dr. Shirley Telles – A neuroscientist and one of India’s foremost researchers on yoga and pranayama. Dr. Telles has published extensively on how different yoga breathing practices affect the brain and body. She has used EEG to study meditators performing Bhramari (humming breath) and found increases in alpha waves and improved focus. She has also researched the cognitive effects of alternate-nostril breathing, finding enhancements in tasks requiring attention and autonomic symmetry. In the last decade, Telles has led studies examining pranayama for stress reduction and cognitive performance in student populations and has contributed to reviews on yoga breathing in health care. Her work is important for blending ancient somatic practices with modern experimental design, and she often provides an Eastern perspective in global breathwork research forums.

  • Dr. Andrew Huberman & Dr. David Spiegel – These Stanford University researchers co-authored the influential 2023 breathwork vs. meditation study discussed above ( Brief structured respiration practices enhance mood and reduce physiological arousal - PMC ) ( Brief structured respiration practices enhance mood and reduce physiological arousal - PMC ). Andrew Huberman (a neuroscientist) and David Spiegel (a psychiatrist and hypnosis expert) are both advocates of controlling physiological state to improve mental health. Huberman has popularized breathwork through public science communication, explaining practices like cyclic sighing in podcasts and interviews, while Spiegel’s interest comes from decades of mind-body therapy research (e.g., hypnosis for stress). Their collaboration brought a high level of scientific rigor and visibility to breathwork research. By using biometric devices and a large sample in their study, they set new standards for how to evaluate breath-based interventions. Huberman, in particular, often cites neurophysiological mechanisms (like CO₂/O₂ balance and vagal activation) on why certain breathing patterns work, effectively acting as a bridge between laboratory findings and public adoption of breathwork. Given their academic standing, their endorsement of breathwork has helped attract more researchers to examine breathing techniques through a scientific lens.

These are just a few of the notable contributors. Others could be mentioned – for example, Dr. Richard Davidson (at University of Wisconsin) who integrated breath awareness in mindfulness research, or Emma Seppälä (Yale/Stanford) who studied breathing-based meditation for PTSD in veterans, or Enzo Tagliazucchi (Argentina) who is probing breathwork’s effects on consciousness using EEG. The field is truly interdisciplinary, spanning clinical innovators, neuroscientists, psychophysiologists, and traditional practitioners. Together, they are building the evidence base for breathwork and slowly unraveling the best ways to harness the breath for healing and well-being.

Unanswered Questions and Research Gaps

Despite significant progress, there remain many unanswered scientific questions about breathwork. Current research only scratches the surface of the myriad techniques and experiences reported anecdotally. Here are some key gaps and open questions:

  • What are the optimal protocols for different outcomes? The term “breathwork” covers everything from 5-minute daily exercises to multi-hour holotropic sessions. It’s unclear which breathing patterns, frequencies, or session lengths are ideal for specific goals (e.g. anxiety relief vs. depression vs. trauma processing). Studies have largely focused on slow breathing around 6 breaths/min or variations of yogic breathing, but direct comparisons between techniques are rare. As one review pointed out, future research needs to standardize and optimize breathwork practices for clinical use ( Breathwork Interventions for Adults with Clinically Diagnosed Anxiety Disorders: A Scoping Review - PMC ) ( Breathwork Interventions for Adults with Clinically Diagnosed Anxiety Disorders: A Scoping Review - PMC ). For instance, is it the extended exhale that matters most for stress reduction, or the mere slowing of breath? How many minutes per day are needed to see sustained benefits? These dosage and protocol questions remain to be systematically tested.

  • Mechanisms: How exactly does breathwork exert its effects? We know breathing can change CO₂ and O₂ levels, heart rate, blood pressure, and neural oscillations. However, the precise chain of events linking a given technique to an outcome is not fully mapped. Multiple mechanisms likely operate in parallel – including biochemical (gas changes, pH shifts), neurological (stimulation of vagal afferents, locus coeruleus modulation), psychological (focused attention, expectation), and somatic (muscle relaxation, posture change). Untangling these will require carefully controlled experiments. For example, is the calming effect of slow exhalation due mostly to activating stretch receptors in the lungs (which signal safety to the brain), or due to increased CO₂ which indirectly tranquilizes the mind? Some hypotheses, like the nasal airflow triggering the olfactory bulb to synchronize brain activity ( How Breath-Control Can Change Your Life: A Systematic Review on Psycho-Physiological Correlates of Slow Breathing - PMC ), are still speculative and need confirmation. Understanding mechanisms is not just academic – it could help tailor techniques to individuals (some people might respond more to one pathway than another).

  • Individual differences: People respond variably to breathwork. While many find it helpful, some may feel dizziness, anxiety, or emotional discomfort, especially with vigorous methods. We don’t fully know who benefits most or least from breathwork. Could genetic factors, personality traits, or baseline physiology predict someone’s response? For instance, people with panic disorder might initially struggle with breathwork that involves breath-holding or faster breathing, due to sensitivity to CO₂ changes. Likewise, those with trauma might experience intense emotions during breathwork. Research is needed to identify markers (physiological or psychological) that indicate the best approach for each individual. This ties into the personalized medicine aspect – breathwork might be very effective, but not one-size-fits-all. Clinicians currently rely on trial-and-error when introducing breathing exercises; a more evidence-based matching of techniques to patient profiles would be valuable.

  • Long-term effects and adherence: Most studies so far look at immediate or short-term outcomes (weeks to months). We know little about the long-term impacts of regular breathwork practice over years. Does daily breathwork lead to lasting changes in baseline autonomic tone or stress hormone levels? Are there any risks to chronic practice of certain techniques (for example, could habitual hyperventilation practice lead to blood gas imbalances)? On the flip side, adherence can be an issue – some people may find breathwork boring or difficult to stick with outside of a class setting. Research could explore how to increase long-term engagement, perhaps by combining breathwork with biofeedback or apps that motivate users. Additionally, longitudinal studies could see if breathwork practitioners have different health outcomes (like fewer anxiety relapses or better cardiovascular health) after several years.

  • Therapeutic integration: Breathwork often works best in conjunction with other therapies (e.g. mindfulness, yoga, psychotherapy). A gap in research is understanding how to integrate breathwork into standard care. For example, can a brief breathwork exercise at the start of a therapy session enhance the therapy by calming the patient? Some therapists report it does, but controlled studies are needed. Similarly, in medical settings – can teaching pre-surgery patients a breathing exercise reduce their postoperative pain or complications? Early indications are positive in areas like pain management and pulmonary rehab, but more trials would solidify breathwork’s role. Also, the question of safety and contraindications needs clear answers: While generally safe, certain breathwork practices (e.g. prolonged breath holds or heavy hyperventilation) might not be suitable for people with specific medical conditions like severe asthma, cardiovascular issues, or pregnancy. Guidelines on what is safe for whom are still based more on expert opinion than robust data.

  • Neuroscientific mysteries: Breathwork opens up some fundamental scientific questions about the mind-body connection. One intriguing question: could intensive breathwork induce the release of endogenous psychoactive substances (like DMT in the brain)? This idea has been speculated in popular culture and even hinted by some researchers (Can you breathe your way to health, happiness and a psychedelic ...) (This Breathing Technique Can Help You Unlock an Altered State of ...), but it remains unproven. The observed “psychedelic-like” EEG patterns (Breathwork-induced psychedelic experiences modulate neural dynamics - PubMed) beg the question of what neurochemistry underlies them. Additionally, what is the role of consciousness and attention in breathwork’s effects? Most techniques emphasize mindful awareness of breath – is the awareness crucial, or would simply changing breathing rate unconsciously (via a device or pacer) yield the same benefits? Some mechanistic studies have tried separating the cognitive aspect from the mechanical aspect, but it’s challenging since breath awareness itself has calming effects.

  • Somatic breathwork specific research: Given the focus of this report, it’s worth reiterating that somatic breathwork as a distinct modality needs more research attention. Therapists practicing somatic breathwork claim benefits in trauma healing by releasing somatic tension and completing “fight or flight” responses that were frozen in the body. It aligns well with theories like Peter Levine’s Somatic Experiencing. However, scientific validation is minimal so far – there is a need for clinical trials evaluating somatic breathwork in trauma populations (e.g. comparing it to standard trauma-focused therapy or to other relaxation techniques). Documenting physiological changes during somatic breathwork (such as tracking heart rate, tremors or emotional expression) could also help build a model of how it works. The challenge is that outcomes in somatic therapy can be subjective (felt sense of relief, etc.), so researchers will have to define clear metrics for success. This is a ripe area for interdisciplinary study between psychologists, physiologists, and even anthropologists (since somatic practices often draw from non-Western healing traditions).

In essence, while we know breathwork works to an extent, we are still learning why it works so well and how best to apply it. The excitement must be balanced with scientific rigor. As one publication cautioned, we should avoid a “miscalibration between hype and evidence” ( Effect of breathwork on stress and mental health: A meta-analysis of randomised-controlled trials - PMC ) – breathwork is not magic, and it may not replace other treatments, but it does hold genuine potential as revealed by early studies. Addressing these open questions through well-designed research will help breathwork transition from a trendy wellness practice to an accepted, evidence-based component of healthcare and psychology.

Surprising and Notable Discoveries

Breathwork has yielded some surprising discoveries and intriguing effects that highlight the extraordinary influence of breathing on the body and mind. Here are a few of the most noteworthy or unexpected findings:

  • Immune System Modulation: Perhaps one of the most startling findings is that breathwork can influence the immune system – something once thought entirely automatic. The Wim Hof Method studies showed that through a combination of breathing techniques and mindset, people could voluntarily trigger a flood of adrenaline that suppressed pro-inflammatory pathways in the body ( Does the Wim Hof Method have a beneficial impact on physiological and psychological outcomes in healthy and non-healthy participants? A systematic review - PMC ). This led to reduced fever, fewer sickness symptoms, and lower levels of inflammatory cytokines during an endotoxin challenge, outcomes previously deemed impossible without medication. The idea that simply changing how one breathes for a few minutes can alter the course of an immune response (at least temporarily) was a paradigm-shifting observation. It opens the door to using breathwork as a complementary approach for conditions involving inflammation or autoimmunity – a surprising concept that researchers are now exploring further.

  • Altered States and Endogenous Psychedelics: Breathwork’s capacity to induce altered states of consciousness akin to psychedelic drugs is both a classic anecdote and a modern scientific finding. Participants in holotropic breathwork have long reported visual imagery, feelings of oneness, and deep spiritual experiences. What’s remarkable is that this is being validated with brain data: increased neural signal complexity during intense breathwork mirrors what is seen under substances like psilocybin (Breathwork-induced psychedelic experiences modulate neural dynamics - PubMed). Some scientists speculate that extreme breathing (especially coupled with meditation) might stimulate the pineal gland or other brain regions to release trace amounts of psychoactive compounds (e.g., dimethyltryptamine), potentially contributing to the vivid experiences – though this remains unconfirmed. Even without invoking neurochemistry, the fact that guided hyperventilation and breath control can reliably produce “non-ordinary” states in many people is surprising to those who think only external chemicals can do so. It suggests the human body has built-in pathways to unlock these states through breath and rhythm, a finding that blurs the line between physiology and phenomenology.

  • Heat Generation (Tummo Yoga): A dramatic demonstration of mind-body control via breath is the ability of Tibetan Tummo meditators to raise their body temperature. Researchers from Harvard in the 1980s documented monks using a forceful breath technique and visualization to dry soaked blankets in a cold room, raising skin temperature by as much as 17°F in fingers and toes (Mind over matter? Core body temperature controlled by the brain) (Meditation changes temperatures - Harvard Gazette). More recently, a 2013 study showed that even novices could learn aspects of Tummo to increase core temperature slightly (Tummo breathing: Benefits and how to do it - MedicalNewsToday). This challenges our understanding of thermoregulation – ordinarily, humans cannot significantly increase core temperature without external heat or vigorous exercise. Through breath control and focus, the monks essentially activated brown adipose tissue and other metabolic heat production. This is a surprising physiologic feat with potential practical implications (e.g., staying warm in cold environments or boosting metabolism). It underscores how breathwork can tap into deep autonomic processes once thought unchangeable at will.

  • Nasal Breathing and Memory: An unexpected nuance in breath research is the role of nasal breathing in cognitive function. Studies have found that we naturally breathe differently when concentrating or remembering things (often we even hold our breath briefly, a phenomenon called “respiratory pause” during memory tasks). One study discovered that breathing through the nose, as opposed to the mouth, during learning led to better memory retention – possibly because nasal breathing oscillations synchronized activity in memory-related brain areas like the hippocampus ( Brief structured respiration practices enhance mood and reduce physiological arousal - PMC ). This was surprising because it suggests the route of airflow can modulate brain function beyond just oxygen delivery. It gives some credence to yoga teachings that prefer nasal breathing for its subtle effects on energy and focus. So something as simple as “close your mouth and breathe through your nose” might actually influence how well you think and remember, a quirky finding that bridges respiratory physiology and neuroscience.

  • Rapid Mood Enhancement: While we expect breathing exercises to calm us, one might not anticipate that a mere five minutes of breathing could significantly boost mood in a measurable way. Yet the Stanford trial found just that – such a short daily practice of cyclic sighing had statistically significant effects on positive affect and anxiety reduction ( Brief structured respiration practices enhance mood and reduce physiological arousal - PMC ). The speed and efficiency of this outcome surprised researchers who are used to seeing more gradual changes with interventions. It implies that the body’s emotional state can be hacked almost on-demand through breathing. In a world where antidepressant medications take weeks to work and psychotherapy unfolds over months, the immediacy of breathwork’s effect is a standout discovery. It doesn’t mean breathwork alone can cure clinical depression, of course, but the ability to rapidly shift one’s mood with guided breathing is a tool many people didn’t realize they had at their disposal.

  • Physiological Coherence and Group Effects: Another interesting, if less quantified, observation is that breathwork can induce a sense of interpersonal connection and synchronization. In group breathing sessions (whether a yoga class chanting “Om” or a holotropic workshop), participants often report feeling a strong bond or collective energy. Some preliminary studies using devices have shown that people’s heart rate variability patterns can synchronize when breathing together in a group at the same rhythm. This bio-synchrony is surprising and not fully understood – it could be a combination of auditory cues (hearing others breathing or chanting), psychological suggestion, and genuine energetic coupling via the vagus nerve’s influence. It harkens to practices in many cultures where group breathing or singing is used to foster unity (think of soldiers marching in cadence or congregations singing hymns). Scientifically demonstrating group physiological coherence is challenging, but the anecdotal reports are intriguing and suggest breathwork might even play a role in social neuroscience.

Each of these findings, from the biochemical to the social, highlights how profoundly the act of breathing can influence human physiology and experience. What was once dismissed as a simple relaxation technique now commands serious scientific attention, because these surprises show that breathwork can touch aspects of our being that we didn’t realize were accessible through willful action. As research continues, we may uncover even more unexpected capabilities unlocked by breath – truly earning the breath its ancient reputation as the link between body, mind, and spirit.

Conclusion

Breathwork, and somatic breathwork in particular, has evolved from esoteric practice to an area of genuine scientific inquiry. Modern studies confirm many of the age-old claims: by harnessing the breath, we can steady the heart, calm the mind, and even provoke shifts in consciousness. Physiologically, controlled breathing exercises engage the parasympathetic nervous system, increase heart rate variability, modulate brainwave patterns, and influence stress hormones and inflammation – creating a state of relaxed alertness conducive to healing and well-being ( How Breath-Control Can Change Your Life: A Systematic Review on Psycho-Physiological Correlates of Slow Breathing - PMC ) ( Effect of breathwork on stress and mental health: A meta-analysis of randomised-controlled trials - PMC ). Psychologically, breathwork techniques have been shown to reduce stress, anxiety, and depression symptoms in clinical trials ( Effect of breathwork on stress and mental health: A meta-analysis of randomised-controlled trials - PMC ), and are being applied as therapeutic tools for trauma, panic disorder, and other conditions where bodily regulation is key ( Breathwork Interventions for Adults with Clinically Diagnosed Anxiety Disorders: A Scoping Review - PMC ). A variety of techniques exist – from gentle somatic breathing focused on inner sensations, to vigorous holotropic and Wim Hof methods – each offering a slightly different “doorway” into the mind-body connection. Leading researchers and clinicians are progressively mapping this territory, validating benefits, and understanding mechanisms, though much remains to be discovered about optimizing breathwork for individual needs.

Crucially, breathwork empowers individuals with a degree of self-regulation: it is low-cost, portable, and once learned, always available. The scientific findings to date support the idea that something as simple as conscious breathing can have measurable impacts on one’s physiology and mood, which is both inspiring and practical. At the same time, researchers urge a balanced view – breathwork is not a panacea, and rigorous studies must continue to separate fact from hype ( Effect of breathwork on stress and mental health: A meta-analysis of randomised-controlled trials - PMC ). Questions about long-term effects, ideal techniques for specific goals, and underlying neural processes are stimulating further research, much of it currently underway.

In the coming years, we can expect to see breathwork integrated more into mainstream health and psychology, guided by evidence from ongoing studies. Somatic breathwork, with its emphasis on bodily felt sense and trauma release, is an exciting frontier that bridges psychology and physiology – and scientific validation of its methods will be especially impactful for trauma therapy. Meanwhile, the “surprises” from breathwork research remind us of the untapped potential within our own bodies: from boosting our immune response to altering our consciousness, the breath is a powerful instrument we are only beginning to fully understand. As the scientific story of breathwork continues to unfold, it reinforces a simple, profound truth: how we breathe has a profound effect on how we live – affecting our body, mind, and perhaps even the depths of our awareness ( How Breath-Control Can Change Your Life: A Systematic Review on Psycho-Physiological Correlates of Slow Breathing - PMC ) (Breathwork-induced psychedelic experiences modulate neural dynamics - PubMed).

Sources: The information in this report is drawn from a range of contemporary studies and reviews on breathwork. Key references include clinical trials and meta-analyses on breathwork’s mental health effects ( Effect of breathwork on stress and mental health: A meta-analysis of randomised-controlled trials - PMC ) ( Breathwork Interventions for Adults with Clinically Diagnosed Anxiety Disorders: A Scoping Review - PMC ), neuroscience research on breathing and brain function (Study shows how slow breathing induces tranquility) ( How Breath-Control Can Change Your Life: A Systematic Review on Psycho-Physiological Correlates of Slow Breathing - PMC ), and specific studies of techniques like slow pranayamic breathing ( How Breath-Control Can Change Your Life: A Systematic Review on Psycho-Physiological Correlates of Slow Breathing - PMC ), Holotropic Breathwork ( Measure of Significance of Holotropic Breathwork in the Development of Self-Awareness - PMC ), and the Wim Hof Method ( Does the Wim Hof Method have a beneficial impact on physiological and psychological outcomes in healthy and non-healthy participants? A systematic review - PMC ). Notable contributions from leading institutions (Stanford University ( Brief structured respiration practices enhance mood and reduce physiological arousal - PMC ), Cambridge University (Breathwork-induced psychedelic experiences modulate neural dynamics - PubMed), Radboud UMC ( Does the Wim Hof Method have a beneficial impact on physiological and psychological outcomes in healthy and non-healthy participants? A systematic review - PMC ), among others) and researchers (e.g. Grof, Porges, Brown & Gerbarg, Krasnow, Huberman) have been cited throughout to provide an evidence-based picture of what is known, and what remains to be explored, about the science of breathwork.

Evan Drake https://simhasana.com
Previous

Somatic Breathwork Tips for a One-Hour Session (Beginner’s Guide)